Let's take a look at the comparison between Samsung HW-R450 and Yamaha ATS-1070. It will become clear that among these two devices, the ATS-1070 is more suitable for the role of a home soundbar. According to the results of our comparison, HW-R450 received 4 points out of 10 possible, and ATS-1070 was rated 6,6 points.
Each of the compared models received 6 points for the audio features.
It worth understanding the difference between the two types of amplification: a passive soundbar does not have its own amplifier and receives amplification from the signal source, while an active soundbar has a built-in amplifier. The same active type of amplification is used in the HW-R450 and the ATS-1070.
There are stereo soundbars and multichannel ones. It is with the help of multichannel devices that you can get volumetric sound. It is worth noting one of the main differences, the HW-R450 has 2.1 channels, while the ATS-1070 has 2.0 channels. Also, the output power of the soundbars under consideration is different, Samsung HW-R450 has 200 (overall) W, and 120 W has the competitor.
|Output power, W||200 (overall)||120|
|Separate speaker (in package)||0||0|
|Separate speaker connections||wireless||wired|
Soundbars can have a built-in or external subwoofer. The first type is inseparable from the soundbar body, but for the second, you can choose a good location for deep bass. A built-in subwoofer is only present in the ATS-1070. The HW-R450 comes with an external subwoofer.
|Separate subwoofer (in package)||✔||✖|
|Separate subwoofer connections||wireless||✖|
Unlike stereo, when reproducing multichannel sound, each specific direction of sound corresponds to its dedicated channel with a separate independent loudspeaker, which creates a three-dimensional sound stage. The HW-R450 received rating 4 out of 10 for multichannel audio processing, but the ATS-1070, in the same category, earned 6 out of 10 points.
The peculiarity of Dolby Atmos is that this format is object-oriented, that is, each object of the audio signal is sounded separately and linked to its spatial location. If we look at the models in terms of Dolby Atmos support, then none of these soundbars can work with this technology.
DTS:X is an algorithm for processing sound scenes by the processor, linking directly to objects, rather than channels, and calculating the optimal distribution of sound output in a room. This ability to reproduce surround sound with DTS:X technology is not implemented in any of the soundbars in this comparison.
|Dolby (other)||Dolby Digital||Dolby Digital, Dolby Pro Logic II|
|DTS (other)||has not||DTS Digital Surround|
The possibility to listen online to millions of songs from one device has become a reality thanks to streaming services.
The popular Spotify service is available on the ATS-1070.
|Apple Music (AirPlay)||✖||AirPlay|
|Other streaming services||has not||Pandora, Tuneln, Deezer, Chromecast|
The existence of a sufficient number of current connectors significantly expands the functionality of the device. For example, only through HDMI is it possible to implement the transfer of object-oriented formats, and the presence of a Bluetooth connection will allow remote control, etc. The devices received different ratings for connectivity: Samsung HW-R450 was rated 5 out of 10, and Yamaha ATS-1070 was rated 6 out of 10.
The presence of Wi-Fi in the soundbar allows you to get rid of wires when connected to a sound source and get minimal audio latency when playing content from streaming services. Such connection as via Wi-Fi is not possible on any of the devices in comparison.
Bluetooth connection is now one of the main communication protocols for speaker systems, which provides excellent quality and minimal audio latency. The availability of Bluetooth protocol, we can see in both models.
HDMI ARC is a very usefull technology that creates a two-way communication channel between a TV and another device. This is convenient since there is no need to use optical and other cables in the system. HDMI ARC is a feature unique to Yamaha ATS-1070.
|Optical digital input/output||1/0||1/0|
|USB||1 (USB 2.0)||✖|
|Coaxial digital input/output||0/0||0/0|
|Analog audio input/output (RCA)||0/0||1/0|
Voice control is designed to make operating the device more convenient. This allows you to control basic soundbar functions from anywhere in the room.
Proprietary applications allow you to control your soundbars remotely. This is possible both via Bluetooth and Wi-Fi. The ATS-1070 has its own remote control application. None of these soundbars have a built-in microphone.
Some soundbars can be part of a multi-room system and it is an affordable solution for sounding the whole house. However, it is impossible to create a multiroom system based on each of these soundbars.
|Size (Wx H x D), cm/in||89 x 5 x 5/35.7 x 2.1 x 2.7||88.9 x 5.1 x 12.7/35 x 2.1 x 5.1|